First posted on Instagram
All 13 Democrats on the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee stayed away from the panel's executive session on Wednesday, November 18, and Republicans pressed ahead without them, voting 15-0 to advance President Donald Trump's nominee for the Federal Communications Commission, Danielle Thumann Severs, to the full Senate. Sen. Bernie Moreno of Ohio, a Republican on the committee, criticised the Democrats for refusing to take part, calling their boycott "a total disgrace" during the meeting, TheDesk.net reported. The session's agenda also carried 12 bills, four nominations and a package of Coast Guard promotions.
The vote matters because the FCC writes the rules for the television stations, phone networks and internet providers Americans use every day — and a confirmed Thumann Severs would give Republicans a 3-1 majority on the five-member commission, with enough members to act without a single Democrat. The timing is the other half of the story: Democrats won the Senate in the November 3 midterms and take the majority in January, so the outgoing Republican majority is using its final weeks to lock in nominees before the gavel changes hands.
The Democrats say they are not boycotting for its own sake. All 13 signed a letter to Chairman Ted Cruz on Monday asking him to pull Thumann Severs from the agenda and hold her until the next Congress, when she could be considered alongside the renomination of the commission's lone Democrat, Anna Gomez, and the nomination of another Democrat. "There is no mandate for the outgoing majority to rush through a partisan FCC nomination in its final weeks," they wrote. Sen. Ben Ray Luján went further in a separate letter, saying records obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests appear to contradict Thumann Severs' testimony at her November 10 confirmation hearing, where she told senators she had not worked with FCC Chairman Brendan Carr on any media-related issues — the records, he said, show she helped draft commitments Skydance made to win approval for its Paramount merger and worked on matters involving CBS's "60 Minutes" and Jimmy Kimmel. The advocacy group Free Press Action accused her of misleading lawmakers.
Cruz answered that Democrats were throwing a "temper tantrum" and called it a "terrible harbinger" for the next Congress, while telling Reuters that Republicans did not boycott hearings when Democrats were in charge under President Joe Biden. "We are headed into two years of total obstruction," he said of the Democrats' approach once they take over in January. Moreno's own criticism landed in the same session: he called the empty Democratic seats a disgrace while the committee moved ahead with the work.
The dozen bills on the agenda ranged from the COLLUDE Act on government interference in content moderation to the Chip EQUIP Act on semiconductor equipment, the PROOF Act, the Telecommunications Cybersecurity and Resilience Act and the Trucker Bathroom Access Act — alongside nominations for an assistant secretary of transportation, two NASA posts and the Coast Guard promotion lists. Under the committee's own rules, reporting a nomination requires a majority of members including at least one from the minority, with proxy votes not counting — but the Senate's standing rules require only a physical majority, and with all 15 Republicans present, the panel had one. That is how the 15-0 vote went ahead despite the boycott.
Thumann Severs, a senior counsel to Carr, was nominated by Trump in August to fill one of the commission's two open seats. The FCC currently has two Republicans and one Democrat — Gomez, whose term expired on June 30 and who remains in holdover status — and the agency is weighing the fate of Walt Disney's eight company-owned ABC television stations. Carr has faced criticism this year for threatening the licences of those stations and for his scrutiny of television hosts including Kimmel. Democrats also worry that once Thumann Severs is confirmed, Trump could move against Gomez, since the commission would still hold a quorum without her. Sen. Moreno spoke about the lame-duck nominations push alongside Majority Leader John Thune at a briefing on Tuesday, the day before the session.
The nomination now goes to the full Senate, where Thumann Severs needs only a simple majority to be confirmed. With the lame-duck session running down and Democrats set to take control in January, the vote is expected to come quickly — and if she is confirmed, the FCC will enter the new Congress with a Republican majority that can act without Democratic votes.