Senators on the Agriculture Committee pressed President Trump's two nominees for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission on Tuesday to admit, on the record, that the sports event contracts sold by prediction markets are sports betting under another name — and both men refused. Nathan Anonick, the Republican nominee, and Matthew Rowland, the Democratic nominee, told the committee at their confirmation hearing that federal courts have disagreed on the question, that they would not tip the scales while the cases are live, and that the Supreme Court will likely have the final say over who regulates the markets — Washington's CFTC or the states and tribes.
Why it matters is sitting in millions of pockets. Prediction-market apps let anyone in America put money on a game from a phone, in states that never legalised that bet, paying no state gambling tax and playing outside the state rules built to protect bettors. If the contracts are gambling, states and tribes set the rules, collect the taxes and enforce the safeguards, as they have since the Supreme Court handed sports betting back to them in 2018. If they are federal financial products, one markets regulator in Washington decides, and the states lose that say. The answer decides who protects the bettor, who guards the tribal gaming rights Congress recognised, and who gets the money.
The senators asking the questions wanted one word — yes. Senator Tina Smith of Minnesota put it point-blank: is there any practical difference between a sports wager and a sports-event contract? "It seems to me that if it walks like a bet and quacks like a bet, it in fact a bet," she said. "I actually think the law is quite clear, that jurisdiction over sports betting rests in the hand of the states and tribes," Smith said, arguing that the law's ban on gaming contracts makes the contracts "a bet in any other name." Ranking member Amy Klobuchar pressed Rowland on the agency's own rulebook: the CFTC's Regulation 40.11, written in 2011, bars exchanges from listing event contracts involving gaming, war, terrorism or assassination — so what duty does the agency itself have to examine whether a contract crosses that line?
Neither nominee would give them the word. Rowland pointed to Regulation 40.11 and said the agency must "think long and hard about balancing the public interest against the kind of economic usefulness of these contracts," adding: "It's hard for me to comment on active litigation that the CFTC is engaged in, but I'm certainly very sympathetic to the concerns that the states and tribes have raised and would want to work with them further if I was confirmed." Anonick said the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC discretion to find a contract against the public interest, gaming being one of the listed factors, but on the core question he held his line: federal courts have disagreed, and "I wouldn't want to tip the scales on that." When Anonick called it a charged, emotional issue, Smith pushed back: "I don't think that this is an emotional issue. I think this is a legal issue." Both men pledged to fully support whatever the Supreme Court rules, and Rowland predicted a decision "within the next term or the one after."
The hearing's sharpest exchange was about the man the nominees would join. Senator Adam Schiff reminded the room that Chairman Michael Selig, at his own confirmation hearing in November 2025, pledged to "follow the courts" and called himself a "blank slate" on the markets. "I don't know whether he was lying to us, or once confirmed he had an epiphany, but he has been anything but a blank slate. He has not looked to the courts, he has filed briefs telling the courts what to do," Schiff said, accusing Selig of having "blatantly deceived" him. Schiff then put Selig's old question to the new men — is a sports event contract on Thursday night's NFL game between the Indianapolis Colts and the Houston Texans the same as sports betting? Anonick answered for himself: "I appreciate the practical argument. I just say it's legally complex."
The fight behind the hearing is already in court. Under Selig, the CFTC claims "exclusive jurisdiction" over event contracts, and on October 9 it proposed a rule defining "swap" to cover them — putting sports and politics contracts under federal commodities law rather than state gambling law. On November 5 the agency ordered prediction markets to drop the geographic restrictions states had demanded, and nine Democratic senators, Klobuchar, Schiff and Elissa Slotkin among them, wrote this week asking the CFTC to reverse that order. The CFTC and the Justice Department have sued Louisiana and Arkansas this month to defend the federal claim; nearly a dozen states and the agency are suing each other, and courts have taken opposing sides. Minnesota passed the nation's first ban on prediction markets last May, only for a federal judge to block it temporarily — and Selig's CFTC has sued Minnesota along with 11 other states, Republican- and Democratic-led alike.
The two men at the witness table know the agency from inside. Anonick, of Virginia, is legislative counsel to the committee's own chairman, John Boozman, who called his work "invaluable"; he is nominated for a term running to June 19, 2031. Rowland, of the District of Columbia, is a longtime CFTC lawyer who worked its fraud and enforcement cases and served as general counsel to former commissioner Kristin Johnson; he would serve the rest of a term expiring April 13, 2028, and told the panel the growing agency should also beef up its staff. The White House sent both nominations on November 12, part of a bipartisan slate that also named two SEC commissioners. If both are confirmed, the five-member commission rises from one member — Selig alone for nearly a year — to three, with two seats still empty. Selig called the pair "two strong bipartisan picks."
No vote was taken on Tuesday. Chairman Boozman closed the hearing with the record held open for two business days; the committee must vote before the nominations reach the full Senate, and the clock is tight — a new Congress arrives in January, and nominations not finished by then generally have to be sent back and resubmitted. The bigger question the senators could not get answered in the hearing room is now travelling the road both nominees pointed to: through the federal courts, toward a Supreme Court decision that will settle, for every bettor, state and tribe in America, whether a bet by another name is still a bet.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, who has run the commission alone for nearly a year and claims exclusive federal jurisdiction over event contracts — Senator Schiff accused him of breaking his confirmation pledge to "follow the courts." Photo: U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, via Wikimedia Commons.
Senator Tina Smith of Minnesota, who pressed both nominees to admit the contracts are bets: "If it walks like a bet and quacks like a bet, it in fact a bet." Photo: U.S. Senate, via Wikimedia Commons.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here