First posted on Instagram
Senator Ted Cruz confronted Senator Cory Booker during the Senate Judiciary Committee’s nominations hearing on Wednesday, after Booker and other Democrats objected to Republicans pushing seven of President Donald Trump’s judicial nominees through in the lame-duck session. Cruz answered that Democrats had done exactly what they were now criticising, confirming 22 federal judges during the 2024 lame-duck session before leaving power, and accused Booker of hypocrisy.
The clash is about who gets to fill lifetime seats on the federal bench. Republicans have until January 3, when Democrats take control of the Senate and the Judiciary Committee gavel, to confirm the rest of Trump’s picks; any nomination not confirmed by then goes back to the White House and has to start over. The Senate has already confirmed 56 of Trump’s judges in his second term, and about two dozen nominees are still waiting for action.
Booker, at the close of the three-hour hearing, called the rush “another cynical effort” driven by short-term political gain, and said he was yet again “watching the norms of the Senate and the constitutional dictates be undermined for petty political advantage.” The committee’s top Democrat, Dick Durbin, said in his opening statement that Republicans were violating longstanding bipartisan norms: the hearing came just eight days after the last nominations hearing, and some nominees’ questionnaires arrived only 14 days ago — one just seven days ago — against a rule going back to the George W. Bush administration that the committee does not hold a hearing until at least 28 days after the questionnaire is submitted.
Cruz defended the pace by pointing to the 22 federal judges Democrats confirmed in late 2024, in the final weeks of Joe Biden’s presidency, before Democrats lost their hold on Congress. The point cuts both ways: Democrats say the current rush breaks the committee’s own rules, while Republicans say Democrats set the precedent when they were the ones confirming judges after losing an election.
The seven nominees heard on Wednesday were James Cody Hiland, nominated to the Eighth Circuit; Philip Lawrence Aubart, for the Middle District of North Carolina; Brian S. Meyers, for the Eastern District of North Carolina; Eric James Hamilton, for the District of Nebraska; William Grayson Lambert, for the District of South Carolina; Joseph Patrick Falvey, for the Northern District of Indiana; and James P. Sullivan, for the Western District of Texas. Democrats pressed the nominees on whether they could rule independently of the administration and on their views about the 2020 election and January 6, 2021, and Senator Richard Blumenthal asked all seven whether Joe Biden won the 2020 election.
The hearing also exposed a split on the Republican side. Texas Senator John Cornyn withheld his blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel chief nominated for a Dallas federal judgeship, so Gaiser did not appear at the hearing. “He’s not from Texas,” Cornyn told Reuters. “He has no trial experience, and the White House was trying to jam him down our throat without adequate vetting for a lifetime job.” Cruz, who supports Gaiser, warned the White House had indicated it would be “impossible for a brand-new nominee to complete the FBI background check fast enough to be confirmed,” adding: “If the Senate Judiciary Committee does not move Gaiser forward, the people of Texas will pay the price because it will effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats, who will keep it vacant in perpetuity.” Gaiser, 37, a former Ohio solicitor general who clerked for Justice Samuel Alito, was first approached about the judgeship by Cruz’s staff on November 4, the day after the election.
The White House said it expects all of Trump’s judicial nominees to be confirmed by year’s end. Two other Trump nominees have already run into home-state Republican resistance since the midterms: the White House withdrew Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the Eighth Circuit on November 10 and named Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland instead, after opposition from Arkansas’ Republican senator. With the Senate due to hand the gavel to Democrats on January 3, the committee’s next moves — and whether the seven heard on Wednesday reach floor votes before Christmas — will decide how many of the remaining seats Republicans fill and how many stay open.