First posted on Instagram
The Justice Department has charged 15 people in a nationwide crackdown on fraud targeting veterans' benefits, announcing on Tuesday that the alleged schemes drained more than $3.4 million from programs meant for the men and women who served. The enforcement surge, run with the Department of Veterans Affairs and its inspector general during National Veterans Awareness Week, is the first coordinated national operation of its kind by the department's National Fraud Enforcement Division, with 17 U.S. Attorneys' Offices taking part since September 1. Prosecutors also pointed to guilty pleas, trial verdicts and sentencings in related cases over the same period involving more than $19 million in intended losses.
For the veterans at the centre of the cases, the money at stake was not abstract. It was disability pay, money for around-the-clock care and benefits meant to cover the living expenses of people who, in many of the cases, cannot manage their own finances because of the injuries and illnesses they carry from service. The department's message, delivered by Assistant Attorney General Colin M. McDonald, who leads the National Fraud Enforcement Division, was that those benefits were earned — "earned through service, sacrifice, deployments, injuries, time away from loved ones, and a willingness to serve something larger than themselves" — and that the crackdown exists to protect them and the taxpayers who fund them.
The starkest case in the announcement comes from Ohio. Darlene K. Toman, 64, of Painesville, was a court-appointed fiduciary — the person the VA trusted to manage the finances of 11 disabled veterans. Prosecutors say she instead stole more than $940,000 from them. An indictment unsealed in October charges her with six counts of bank fraud, six counts of wire fraud and four counts of aggravated identity theft. The veterans whose money she managed live with schizophrenia, traumatic brain injuries, epilepsy, heart failure, amputations and bipolar disorder, the Justice Department said, and some need around-the-clock care and cannot manage their finances on their own. One of the victims is a decorated Marine Corps veteran who was severely wounded in combat in Iraq and received the Purple Heart and the Combat Action Ribbon. Rather than safeguard the funds, the indictment alleges, Toman drafted fraudulent checks payable to herself and diverted benefit payments meant for the veterans' essential living expenses and care. The case is being prosecuted in the Northern District of Ohio.
In Florida, the fraud left a building that was never built. The VA paid about $4.8 million under an $8.9 million contract for a Cancer Infusion Therapy Center at the Bay Pines VA Medical Center, a contract reserved for service-disabled veteran-owned small businesses. Matthew West and Kevin Kutina were convicted at trial of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and major fraud against the United States after evidence showed they won the contract through false statements about who would actually do the work, with millions flowing to companies that were not eligible for the set-aside. The project was plagued by construction failures, the partially completed center was demolished, and it was never rebuilt.
The other cases in the announcement show how many different ways the benefits were targeted. In Texas, Heidi Brady, a VA National Call Center employee in Killeen, is accused of using her access to veterans' information to change direct-deposit details shortly before monthly disability payments were issued, diverting the money to an account she controlled. Also in Texas, Yolanda Johnson Sayed, 61, a prosthetics representative at the Houston VA Medical Center, is accused of conspiring with a VA-approved vendor to steer purchase orders to the company and approve inflated delivery charges for wheelchairs, walkers and other mobility equipment — about 1,437 transactions between November 2020 and August 2025, worth about $182,000. In Florida, Michael Christopher Comiskey is accused of converting about $69,916 in VA benefits that kept being paid after a veteran's death. In Washington, D.C., Shawn Lightfoot is accused of systematically defrauding his 78-year-old disabled veteran neighbour, opening credit cards in the veteran's name and using the money to finance his own businesses, taking about $150,000. Two school operators, Zachary Somers Hiscock and Arif Hasan Sayed, were convicted for a scheme that paid recruiters based on the GI Bill tuition benefits generated by enrolled veterans, contrary to federal rules; one school's VA-related revenue grew from about $65,000 in 2018 to $2.28 million in 2021. And in West Virginia, Barbara Ferrell pleaded guilty to taking about $114,660.82 in VA fiduciary benefits meant for a family member.
Alongside the charges, the Fraud Division announced a new Texas Federal Fraud Task Force, bringing together all four U.S. Attorneys' Offices in Texas — led by Ryan Raybould, Aaron Reitz, Justin Simmons and Jay Combs — with federal, state and local law enforcement to pursue fraud across the state, which has the largest veteran population in the country. "When you defraud the VA, you defraud veterans who are owed benefits and you defraud the taxpayer for providing them," Reitz said at the announcement in Houston. VA Inspector General Cheryl Mason said her office "works aggressively to identify fraud across the entire VA enterprise and hold offenders accountable."
All of the newly charged defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court, and the charges are allegations, not findings. The cases now move through the federal courts, with the Ohio fiduciary case, the Texas call-center and prosthetics cases and the others proceeding in their districts — and the new Texas task force beginning its work as the department says the nationwide focus on veterans' benefits fraud will continue.