President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping ended the first three-way summit of the three leaders in Shenzhen on Thursday with a four-point joint declaration on United Nations reform, oil supply, the International Criminal Court and nuclear risks — but no deal on Ukraine, no deal on Iran, and no new nuclear arms treaty. The three met for about one hour and 45 minutes at the Kylin Villa, starting nearly two hours behind schedule, and the declaration was published by China's state news agency Xinhua at 6:55 p.m. local time. It is the first document the three leaders have ever signed together.
Why it matters: the declaration touches two things that land directly on households and on the world's safety. The three countries promised to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products and to keep energy flowing — oil supply is what sets fuel prices — and they promised talks on reducing nuclear risks at a moment when there is no binding cap on the world's two largest nuclear arsenals, after the New START treaty expired on February 5. But the document gives no oil volumes, no quotas and no start dates, and it sets no date for the nuclear-risk dialogue it promises, so for now both pledges are words on paper.
The four points, as published by Xinhua and the Kremlin, are: reform the United Nations so it can respond more effectively to global challenges; increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations, and keep energy flows stable; respect the consent of states and the immunities of state officials, with the International Criminal Court and similar bodies told they "must not abuse their jurisdiction"; and reaffirm that "a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought", with the three countries to hold dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.
The court point is the sharpest of the four, and the one with a name behind it: the International Criminal Court has an arrest warrant out for Putin, and Trump used his opening remarks to call the court a "rogue globalist organisation" that had "gotten out of control". Putin did not name nuclear arms in his public opening, the Washington Times reported, listing food and energy security and fighting terrorism instead, and naming a settlement in Ukraine as a shared interest. Xi, according to Xinhua, went further than either of them and called for a complete ban and the elimination of nuclear weapons. Analysts had said before the meeting that it was unlikely to produce major agreements, given the deep differences over Ukraine, Iran, nuclear weapons and trade — and a senior U.S. official had told reporters beforehand: "We do not expect to get to any kind of agreement."
The meeting itself ran late from the start. It had been due to begin at 2:30 p.m. local time, began at about 4:16 p.m., and ended at 6:01 p.m. Putin left the venue at 6:23 p.m. without making any statement to the press. The session took place at the Kylin Villa, a 38-hectare lakeside state guesthouse in the foothills of Kylin Mountain, on the sidelines of the 33rd Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, which Xi was chairing. Trump had arrived in Shenzhen on Wednesday to a personal welcome from Xi at the airport — the first time Xi has greeted any visiting leader at the airport since becoming president — and the three leaders had posed together at the APEC welcome banquet the night before the talks.
What happens next is the G20 leaders' summit in Miami on December 14–15, where Trump and Xi are both expected, and the nuclear-risk dialogue the declaration promises — which has no date, no venue and no named negotiators yet. The wars the three men discussed continue: Russia's offensive in Ukraine is approaching its fifth year, and the war with Iran has closed the Strait of Hormuz to commercial shipping since July. The declaration settles none of that. What it does, for the first time, is put the three leaders' names on one document — and the test now is whether the talks it promises ever happen.