Michael LoSapio, President Donald Trump's nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, told a Senate panel on Thursday that he does not believe the U.S. Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021, and refused to say who won the 2020 presidential election — and within hours, a Republican and a Democrat separately said they will block his nomination.
The answers matter because of the job he is asking for. The agency he would lead — CISA — is the government's main civilian cyberdefence body and the office that helps secure American elections, and its director has to be able to name a threat plainly when he sees one. For voters, the question is whether a man who will not say the Capitol was attacked on a day the whole country watched on television can be trusted to tell the truth about the next attack on an election — and for the Senate, the question is whether to hand him the job before Democrats take control of the chamber in January.
"Was there an attack on the Capitol on January 6, 2021?" Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Connecticut Democrat, asked LoSapio during his confirmation hearing before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee. "I don't know," LoSapio said. "You don't know?" Blumenthal asked. "I don't know how you classify — I don't believe it was an attack," LoSapio said. "I wasn't involved in politics," he added. "I know what I saw on the news." Blumenthal pressed him again, point-blank: was the Capitol attacked on January 6, 2021? "No," LoSapio said. "No, sir." When Blumenthal asked who won the 2020 presidential election, LoSapio said: "I'm not going to answer the question about an election six years ago." "Were you alive on the planet?" Blumenthal asked. "I was," LoSapio said.
LoSapio is the chief information security officer at Palantir, the software company founded by Trump ally Peter Thiel, and the White House defended his selection before the hearing, citing his technical experience and his work protecting Palantir against nation-state threats. Democrats on the committee posted video of the exchange on social media after the hearing and called on the Senate to reject the nomination. Blumenthal had told the nominees his questions were "a test of independence" — and LoSapio was not the only one who failed it: four judicial nominees at the same hearing also would not say the Capitol was attacked, and most of the ten nominees Blumenthal questioned would not say who won the 2020 popular vote.
The resistance to LoSapio is bipartisan, and it is now procedural. Sen. Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, said he will place a hold on the nomination. "You can't have an insurrectionist Palantir executive in charge of our nation's cybersecurity and election security. I will place a hold on Mr. LoSapio's nomination," Wyden told Nextgov/FCW. Sen. Thom Tillis, a North Carolina Republican, separately said he will not support the nomination and plans a hold of his own, Punchbowl News first reported. A hold signals that a senator will object to moving a nomination quickly by unanimous consent; Senate leaders can still pursue confirmation if they have enough support, though doing so consumes time on an already crowded calendar — and Republicans have only the remaining weeks of this Congress to confirm nominees before Democrats take control of the Senate in January.
The vacancy LoSapio would fill has stretched nearly two years. Trump's previous nominee, Sean Plankey, withdrew in April after spending more than a year awaiting confirmation, his nomination entangled in a dispute with Sen. Rick Scott of Florida over Coast Guard contracts. Wyden had previously announced a hold for Plankey, on grounds that CISA had not disclosed the contents of an unclassified 2022 report outlining security vulnerabilities in the U.S. telecom sector; that report was made public through Bloomberg reporting on Thursday, following a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit. If LoSapio's nomination is still pending when this Congress ends, Trump would have to nominate him again — and with a significant Democratic majority in the next Senate, it would be unlikely he would make it into the job.
What happens next is a question of time and votes. The holds from Wyden and Tillis do not by themselves kill the nomination, but they force the Senate leadership to spend floor time it does not have — and the hearing exchange, now on video, is the record every senator will be asked about. The administration has not said whether it will stand by LoSapio or look for another nominee.