Thursday, November 12, 2026 (7 days ago)
The midterms are over, but the fight over the mail-ballot rule is not. On Thursday, November 12, twelve Republican state attorneys general began the process of appealing a September order by U.S. District Judge Carl Nichols — one of two judges who blocked the U.S. Postal Service from carrying out a plan drawn up in response to an executive order by President Trump. Their aim is to revive the restrictions in time for the 2028 presidential election. The attorneys general represent Alabama, Florida, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota and Texas.
The rule at the centre of the case was released by the Postal Service in late August. It would require states to hand over lists of voters' names and addresses, uploaded to a government portal, before ballots could be delivered — and it would require redesigned ballot envelopes with trackable barcodes. Judge Nichols, a Washington-based judge nominated by Trump himself, issued a preliminary injunction after finding that the Postal Service likely has no power to impose such a requirement on states. His order blocks the plan for all federal elections, including the 2028 presidential race — which is why the states are seeking to overturn it now, even though the midterms have passed. A parallel case produced a similar result in Boston, where District Judge Indira Talwani blocked the rule for the midterm elections, in a challenge brought by voting-rights groups and 24 blue-state attorneys general. The Supreme Court ultimately declined to revive the changes for this year's midterms — the decision this article reported in October.
Before that decision, the administration argued that mail ballots are vulnerable to fraud and sought to tighten the Postal Service's rules for handling them. Democratic-led states and voting-rights groups countered that the president lacks constitutional authority to impose election rules and warned the restrictions would create chaos weeks before voters cast ballots. A federal judge had already blocked the plan, ruling that only Congress can override states' authority over elections. Now the two sides have changed places in one respect: it is the states, not the administration, carrying the appeal. In a court filing, Justice Department attorneys confirmed that the Trump administration will not appeal the Nichols ruling, and the deadline for filing its own notice passed on Thursday.
For households, the stakes are the ballot in the mailbox. If the twelve states win, the 2028 election would be run under rules that require states to hand the Postal Service their voter lists before a single ballot is delivered, and to reprint every ballot envelope with a trackable barcode — a system the judges who blocked it said the Postal Service likely had no power to impose, and that election officials said would have created chaos on a midterm timeline. If they lose, the injunction stands and the 2028 race is run under the old rules. The appeal, filed in Washington, D.C., on Thursday, is the first major movement in the case since the midterm elections — and the next ruling will decide how millions of Americans vote for president.
— What follows is the story as first written · the update is above —
The Supreme Court has declined the Trump administration's bid to tighten mail-in voting rules ahead of November's midterm elections.
The administration argued that mail ballots are vulnerable to fraud and sought to tighten USPS rules for handling them. Democratic-led states and voting rights groups countered that the president lacks constitutional authority to impose election rules and warned the restrictions would create chaos weeks before voters cast ballots.
A federal judge had already blocked the plan, ruling that only Congress can override states' authority over elections and that the administration's demands were unrealistic on this timeline. The administration appealed, but the justices declined to intervene.
Election officials in states that had already begun mailing ballots can now proceed without changing their processes.