White House counsel Will Scharf has ordered federal agencies to get White House clearance before any employee agrees to testify before Congress, directing agency lawyers to consult his office and the White House legislative affairs team first.
The order matters because testimony is how Congress gets answers about what the government has done — how money was spent, who was fired, and what decisions were made in the agencies. A clearance gate at the White House means lawmakers may wait longer for witnesses, or never get them, just as Democrats who won both chambers in the November 3 midterm elections prepare to open investigations when the new Congress is seated in January.
Scharf sent the memo on Monday to the general counsels of federal agencies. It instructs them to follow what it calls the established White House consultation process — a check with the counsel's office and with legislative affairs — before any employee agrees to appear before a congressional committee. Scharf wrote that the administration "will remain disciplined in pursuing the work and service the American people deserve," and he cited Watkins v. United States, the 1957 Supreme Court decision that set the limits of Congress's power to investigate.
The memo follows a letter sent on November 9 by Representative Robert Garcia of California, the ranking Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, demanding documents from the White House. CBS first reported that letter. Garcia responded to the new memo by pointing to the Constitution, saying, "Congress' authority comes from Article I," and that his committee "has every right to expect a prompt response from the executive branch."
The two sides read the same memo differently. The White House presents the consultation process as an established one, designed to protect the confidentiality of executive-branch deliberations while the administration carries out its work. Garcia and other Democrats read it as a gate that lets the White House slow or block testimony before their oversight begins — the same fight that has already played out over preservation demands sent to agencies by the Justice Department's Todd Blanche and over warnings from acting officials about document retention, both already covered on this site.
Before the memo, agencies could agree to send an employee to testify after their own internal review. Now the White House counsel's office and legislative affairs must be consulted first, adding a layer of approval between a committee's request and a witness's appearance. The memo does not say how long the consultation takes, or what happens if the White House objects to a witness appearing.
What happens next is a test of the new Congress. Garcia's committee has signalled it will press for documents and witnesses from January, and the memo's consultation requirement will be tested the first time a committee asks an agency employee to appear. If the White House clears witnesses quickly, the process will look like the routine coordination Scharf describes; if requests stall, Democrats are expected to say the memo is doing exactly what they warned it would.