A federal grand jury has indicted Natalie Greene, the former aide to Rep. Jeff Van Drew who was found zip-tied and cut on a New Jersey trail in July 2025 claiming three armed men attacked her over her work. Prosecutors say the attack was staged — and for the first time, her friend Anamaria Moe, who called 911 with the three-armed-men story, is charged too. Greene faces three counts, Moe two, each carrying up to five years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Both are presumed innocent.
The case began as a report of a politically motivated attack on a congressional staffer. Prosecutors now say the evidence points the other way: the wounds were paid for, the story was rehearsed, and the paper trail led back to the two women themselves.
Prosecutors allege that on July 23, 2025, Greene drove to Pennsylvania and paid a body-scarification artist $500 to cut her face, neck, upper chest and shoulder, supplying a pattern for the cuts in advance. She drove back to New Jersey, picked up Moe, and one of the women wrote "Trump Whore" on Greene's stomach in black ink and a message calling the congressman racist on her back. They drove to a nature preserve in Egg Harbor Township.
Late that night, Moe called 911 and reported that three armed men had attacked them on the trail, saying the men called Greene a racist and a whore and threatened to shoot both women. Officers found Greene lying in the woods just off the trail, her hands and feet bound with black zip ties, her shirt pulled over her head and secured with another zip tie.
The story unravelled, prosecutors say, on the physical evidence: black zip ties from Greene's Maserati matched the ones used to bind her; the FBI visited the Pennsylvania studio and came away with her signed consent form, a $500 cash receipt and photos matching the hospital pictures; and two days before the attack, Moe's phone had searched "zip ties near me." Greene, 27, of Ocean City, was first charged by complaint last November; Moe, 25, appeared Thursday before U.S. Magistrate Judge Sharon A. King in Camden. Van Drew is accused of nothing; his office says Greene no longer works there and hopes she is getting care.