First posted on Instagram
Protesters shouted former Border Patrol commander Greg Bovino off the stage at Rutgers University on Monday evening, forcing police to escort him out of the Douglass Student Center before he returned and finished his speech — and legal scholar Jonathan Turley has now fired back at New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill, saying she scolded the students who invited him instead of the crowd that silenced him.
The clash matters because a sitting governor publicly condemned a student group's invited speaker hours before that speaker was shouted down — and then, in Turley's telling, blamed the hosts rather than the disruptors. If a governor's disapproval is followed by a shutdown on campus, the question Turley raises is a practical one for every student group in the state: can a conservative speaker be heard at a public university at all?
Turley, a law professor at George Washington University, made the case in a column on his own site, JonathanTurley.org, published on Tuesday. "Pandemonium broke out at Rutgers University after College Republicans held an event to hear former border chief Gregory Bovino's views on immigration," he wrote, describing what followed as "the usual cancel campaign: first trying to stop people from hearing Bovino, then disrupting the event." Rather than denouncing what he called "the cancel culture and ideological intolerance that still grips higher education," Turley wrote, Sherrill "denounced the conservative students and the university for allowing his views to be heard on campus."
Sherrill had weighed in earlier on Monday, before the event, saying she was "deeply disappointed in the Rutgers Republicans Club's decision to invite Greg Bovino to speak on campus" and that "giving him a platform is the wrong decision." She urged students attending to challenge him, telling them to "ask him why he chose cruelty over humanity and put Americans' lives at risk in their own communities" and to ask "what part of his oath to the Constitution did he miss." Turley argued that her comments helped fuel the confrontation inside the hall — and that she showed "little self-awareness in denouncing Bovino for 'group think' and intimidation as he is literally chased from a campus hall for simply trying to discuss immigration policies."
Inside the Douglass Student Center in New Brunswick, the event had been scheduled for 6 to 8 p.m. and hosted by the Rutgers Republicans. About 300 people protested outside, according to organizers cited by the New Brunswick Patch, and a petition to cancel the event had drawn more than 1,600 signatures. About a dozen protesters inside the room stood on chairs and shouted Bovino down minutes into his talk, calling him a "Nazi" and a "fascist" and yelling "Get out of here" and "You're not welcome in New Jersey." Police ordered the disruptors to stop or disperse, escorted Bovino off the stage, and he returned minutes later to finish the two-hour talk.
Bovino, who became the face of the Trump administration's immigration crackdowns in Los Angeles, Chicago, Charlotte and Minneapolis, did not back down. He mocked Sherrill from the stage, calling her a "totalitarian communist" and "Kim Jong Sherrill," and asked the crowd: "Show of hands, can we remove 100 million illegal aliens by 2028?" That figure is far above the Department of Homeland Security's estimate of about 11 million people living in the United States without authorization — a gap other outlets covering the event flagged. Bovino was demoted from his commander post in January and retired in March, and he drew heavy scrutiny after federal officers shot and killed two U.S. citizens, Renée Good and Alex Pretti, during the Minneapolis operation he oversaw.
The protest had been organized by the Rutgers Young Democratic Socialists of America and the ICE Out of New Jersey coalition, which had pressed the university to cancel the event. Rutgers said the College Republicans are a recognized student group allowed to invite speakers, that providing space does not amount to university endorsement, and that it remains committed to protecting freedom of expression on campus. Rutgers Republicans president Andrew Joseph defended the invitation as a chance to expose students to different viewpoints, and organizers said the club paid Bovino roughly $730 from student-organization funds.
Turley closed his argument with the contrast at the heart of the Instagram post's framing: "speakers on the far left routinely speak without interruption or protests on campuses," he wrote, while conservative students holding an event to hear the other side drew a condemnation from the governor. "If Sherrill was truly concerned with constitutional values," he wrote, "she could start with the 'indispensable right' of free speech and denounce those who opposed students from inviting figures like Bovino on campus. Instead, she joined the mob in denouncing an event that allowed him to be heard on campus."
Neither Sherrill's office nor Rutgers has announced any discipline arising from the disruption, and no arrests were reported from the event. The episode now sits alongside a run of campus-speaker confrontations this fall — and with Turley's column circulating, the governor's next move, and whether Rutgers revisits how it handles contested speakers, will show whether the university treats the shutdown as a one-night disruption or a precedent.