The Government Accountability Office, Congress's nonpartisan watchdog, ruled on Tuesday, November 17, that the Justice Department, the Department of Housing and Urban Development and NASA broke the law by spending more than $9 billion that Congress had never actually released — money that was available only if the president designated all $12.5 billion of it as emergency funding, a condition the president did not meet. The GAO's legal decision, file B-337988, found that the three agencies violated the Antideficiency Act and must report their violations to Congress.
The money at the centre of the finding is not abstract. The largest share — $6 billion for tenant-based rental assistance and $2 billion for project-based rental assistance — is the housing support that helps low-income families pay rent each month, and HUD alone obligated nearly $8 billion of it. The rest covered the U.S. Marshals Service, federal prisoner detention and the Drug Enforcement Administration at Justice, and NASA's exploration and construction accounts. For households that depend on rental assistance and for taxpayers who fund it, the question the GAO answered is who gets to decide that money is spent: Congress, which wrote the condition into law, or the White House, which spent part of it anyway.
The law in question is section 1110 of the Full-Year Continuing Appropriations Act of 2025, signed on March 15, 2025. Congress designated $12.5 billion as emergency funding for housing support, foreign assistance, domestic law enforcement and scientific research, but section 1110(b) made the money available "only if the President subsequently so designates all such amounts." On March 24, 2025, the president designated only some of the funding, saying the rest — nearly $3 billion — had been "improperly designated by the Congress as [an] emergency" and that he did "not concur that the added spending is truly for emergency needs." The GAO held that the words "all such amounts" plainly mean all of it: "Section 1110(b) requires the President to make a choice: designate all or none of Congress's emergency designations. In other words, section 1110(b) does not give the President the authority to pick and choose which incorporated emergency spending to make available."
The agencies spent the money anyway. According to the GAO's figures, drawn from the agencies' own budget reports, the Justice Department obligated $741 million — $163 million for the Marshals Service, $250 million for federal prisoner detention and $328 million for the DEA. HUD obligated $5.999 billion of its $6 billion tenant-based rental assistance account and $1.972 billion of its $2 billion project-based account. NASA obligated the full $450 million for exploration and $140.8 million for construction. In total the three agencies obligated more than $9.3 billion, and spent about $7.7 billion of it in fiscal year 2025. "Since the President's Message designated less than all of the appropriations designated in section 1110(a), the Message did not make the funds available for obligation and expenditure," the GAO concluded. "Therefore, the Department of Justice, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration violated the Antideficiency Act when they obligated and expended the funds in advance of their legal availability."
The administration's budget office disagreed, and the GAO answered it directly. The Office of Management and Budget argued that the president "need not designate all accounts, just all of the amounts in the accounts that he chooses to designate" — an account-by-account reading. The GAO rejected that, noting that OMB itself had previously read the same provision as an all-or-nothing proposition, and that the statute gives the president no authority to add the words "within each account" to the law Congress wrote. House Appropriations Ranking Member Rosa DeLauro, who asked for the decision with Senate Appropriations Vice Chair Patty Murray, said the ruling "emphasizes that it is Congress that holds the power of the purse, not the President, and not Executive Branch agencies," and demanded the unlawful spending be halted and reported to Congress. Murray put the blame on OMB Director Russ Vought, saying he "brazenly broke the law when refusing to spend billions of dollars in emergency funding Congress provided on a bipartisan basis."
The finding is a legal determination by the GAO, not a court judgment, and it makes no finding that any official knowingly and wilfully violated the law — the Antideficiency Act carries criminal penalties only for knowing and wilful violations. What it does require is that the three agencies formally report their violations to Congress, as the law demands. Whether Congress acts on the finding — through hearings, a demand for the money's return, or a fix in the next spending bill — is the next step, and the decision is already being cited as the Democrats' case that the White House cannot spend money Congress conditioned and never released.