The Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday advanced 11 of President Trump's nominees to the full Senate — three of them lifetime district judges: Robert Long for the Middle District of Florida and Jesus Osete for the Western District of Missouri, each approved 12-10 on party lines, and Peter Mansfield for the Eastern District of Louisiana, approved 14-8 with two Democrats crossing over. The same meeting advanced a U.S. Parole Commission member, three U.S. attorneys and four U.S. marshals. The committee has now advanced 168 nominees in this Congress.
Why it matters is that these are the federal officials ordinary people actually meet. District judges serve for life and decide the cases that reach daily life — election rules, gun laws, immigration, crime. U.S. attorneys choose which federal crimes are prosecuted in their districts; marshals hunt fugitives. Grassley's case for speed is that filled seats mean working courts: Long's Florida seat has been empty since November 2024 and is listed by the federal courts as a judicial emergency.
Chairman Chuck Grassley opened by calling judges, U.S. attorneys and marshals "among the most important nominations that this committee reviews. They're the backbone of our justice system, and the American people need good folks in these roles to keep the wheels of justice moving." Of the judges, he said: "I'm confident that they will preside over cases without fear or favor." The ranking Democrat, Dick Durbin, answered in the same breath: "Republicans are in a mad scramble to confirm as many judicial nominees as possible before the Democrats take majority control of the Senate in January." It met on a Tuesday morning instead of its usual Thursday slot, with nominations hearings on November 10 and 18, eight days apart.
The sharpest fight was over Osete, 35, the number two in the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division under Harmeet Dhillon. "Even among the unqualified and inexperienced nominees put forward by the President, Mr. Osete stands out," Durbin said, accusing him of attacking voting, reproductive and LGBTQ rights; Durbin also spoke against Inabinett. All three judge nominees had declined at their hearings to say Joe Biden won in 2020. Long is a Florida state appeals judge and Navy JAG officer who wrote a 2023 concurrence in a ruling that eliminated a majority-Black congressional district. Mansfield, a longtime Justice Department prosecutor, was the exception to the party-line pattern — Durbin and Senator Mazie Hirono voted for him.
The rest moved with less argument: Stephen Husk to the Parole Commission (17-5); U.S. attorneys Samuel Lee (Eastern District of Tennessee) and Gretchen Shappert (Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands), 14-8 each, and Robert Troester (Western District of Oklahoma), 12-10; marshals Reid Creswell (South Carolina) and James Edge (Western North Carolina), 17-5 each, and Inabinett (Middle District of Alabama) and James Jackson (Eastern District of Texas), 12-10. The rest of the 14-nomination agenda was held over — Oklahoma judge nominees Trevor Pemberton and Zach West again among them — and the Right to Worship bill was set aside pending talks between Durbin's and Senator Ted Cruz's offices.
The 11 now go to the full Senate, where Majority Leader John Thune has only weeks of floor time left — the Senate sits this week and again from November 30 to December 18 — before the Democratic majority elected this month takes over in January. Durbin has already served notice of what changes then: "Senate Republicans turned obstruction of judicial nominees into an art form under President Obama. So, forgive me if I shed no tears when Republicans complain about Democrats refusing to rubberstamp unqualified MAGA nominees once we take the majority in January."
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here