How Close Is Mary Peltola to Winning the Alaska Senate Race Outright?

Mary Peltola is 445 votes short of winning the Alaska Senate race outright. The count the state released on Friday evening, November 13, left the Democrat with 49.84 percent of the first-choice votes counted so far, to Republican Senator Dan Sullivan's 46.09 percent — a lead of 10,412 votes, up from 5,800 after Thursday's update, in the last uncalled Senate race in the country. Under Alaska law, a candidate who finishes with more than half of the first-choice votes wins at once, with no ranked-choice rounds. Peltola has not reached that line yet.
The plain reality is that she can lead by more than 10,000 votes and still not own the seat. The detailed Division of Elections report, timestamped 7:14 p.m. on November 13 and reported by The Alaska Story, puts her at 138,240 votes to Sullivan's 127,828, with 279,334 ballots counted. The division's own live dashboard shows her at 50.0 percent, but Alaska News explains why that number flatters her: the dashboard leaves write-in votes out of the total and rounds to one decimal place. Counting the write-ins, she is 445 votes short of a majority of the votes counted. Leaving them out, she is 17 votes short. That is how close this is — the answer changes depending on which column of the same official count you read.
Sullivan's side says the only honest position is that the counting is not finished. His campaign spokesman Nate Adams has stressed that counting is not complete, and on the numbers he is right about that much: about 10,500 ballots the division had accepted by Friday afternoon were not yet in the results, by Alaska News' count from the division's ballot report, including about 2,600 questioned ballots from Anchorage, Eagle River and Chugiak that voters cast when workers could not confirm their eligibility at the polls. Ballots from overseas can still arrive through November 18.
She has 49.84 percent of first-choice votes to Sullivan's 46.09 percent — and in Alaska, 49.84 is not a win until the ranked-choice count says so.
The common-sense principle is plain: a lead is not a win until the rule that decides the race is met. Alaska chose this rule itself. Voters rank their choices, and a candidate who cannot reach half of the first choices must prove she still wins when the lower candidates are removed and their ballots move to the voters' next choices. Being ahead by 10,412 votes is a strong position. It is not the finish line the law set.
The consequence is that November 18 now decides this race one way or the other. To top 50 percent, Peltola would need about 54 percent of the Senate votes still to be counted, Alaska News calculates — a hard but live path, since she won about 59 percent of the new Senate votes in Friday's update. If she falls short, the race goes to ranked-choice rounds after the final count on November 18, and on the ballot-level file the state posted Friday, Alaska News' math has her finishing about 9,500 votes ahead of Sullivan in that count too, up from about 4,900 on Thursday. Sullivan's road back runs through ballots that have not been counted yet, in both counts at once.
The details that matter are these. The Associated Press estimates about 96 percent of ballots have been counted, Alaska Public Media reported, in a race The Business Standard notes is the only unresolved Senate race in the country: a Peltola win gives the Democrats a 56-seat Senate majority, while a Sullivan hold keeps the caucus at 55. Behind Peltola and Sullivan, Republican Gerald Heikes has 5,885 first-choice votes and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. — the Petersburg candidate whose similar name sits at the centre of the Justice Department lawsuit our blog covered when a judge refused the Peltola campaign the names of voters whose absentee ballots were rejected — has 4,560, with 855 write-ins. Peltola now leads the two Sullivans combined. Certification is targeted for November 25.
So the question the last ballots will answer is not who is ahead. Everyone can see who is ahead. It is whether being ahead by more than 10,000 votes is enough, in a system built to ask one more question after the first count ends. The state's own dashboard already rounds her to 50.0 percent. The count itself has not.